Should Students Wear Uniforms?
Do school uniforms make students equal, or do they take away their freedom to be themselves? Sara, James and teacher Layla share funny memories and strong opinions.
In this episode
Sara
Host
James
Host
Layla
a secondary school teacher in Dubai
Press play to listen
0:00 / 10:42
Chapters
Transcript
Tap any line to listen from there.
- Sara
Hello everyone, and welcome to Yalla Fluent Podcast! I'm Sara, and I'm very happy to be here with you again.
- James
And I'm James. Today we are talking about something almost every student has an opinion about, and that is school uniforms.
- Sara
Our guest today is Layla, who is a secondary school teacher in Dubai. Welcome to the show, Layla!
- Layla
Thank you, Sara. Thanks, James. I'm really happy to be here, because I see uniforms every single day at work.
- James
So you are the perfect person to ask.
- Layla
I will do my best!
- James
Before we start, let me say that I wore a school uniform for thirteen years, so I have strong feelings.
- Sara
And I never wore one! In my school in the United States, we could wear almost anything.
- James
Lucky you! That sounds like a dream.
- Sara
So today we have three very different experiences.
- James
Let me start with my memories. At my school in England, we had to wear a grey jacket, a white shirt, black shoes and a tie. I hated the tie.
- Sara
Why did you hate it? It sounds quite smart to me.
- James
It was smart, but it was also hot and uncomfortable.
- Sara
Oh no, poor James!
- James
Every morning my mother tied it for me, and by lunchtime it was always under my ear.
- Layla
That is funny, James. In Dubai, my uniform was a blue dress with a white scarf, and I actually loved it. I never had to think about what to wear.
- Sara
Really? That is interesting, because I spent a lot of time choosing my clothes before school. Sometimes I changed three times in the morning!
- Layla
Exactly! That is one reason I like uniforms.
- James
That makes sense.
- Layla
In the morning, my students don't worry about their clothes, so they have more energy for learning.
- James
I agree that mornings are easier. But I remember that my friends and I always found ways to make the uniform a little different.
- Sara
Oh, I want to hear this. What did you do?
- James
We wore very bright socks, or we made the tie really short. One boy even wore a pink watch.
- Sara
A pink watch? Brilliant!
- James
The teachers were not happy, but we felt special.
- Layla
My students do the same thing today! They change their shoes, or they wear a special bag. People always want to show who they are.
- Sara
That is a good point. So even with a uniform, young people find a way to be different.
- James
So maybe the uniform is only the starting point, and everyone adds their own style.
- Sara
Let's talk about the big arguments. Layla, what is the strongest reason for uniforms, in your opinion?
- Layla
For me, it is equality. If everybody wears the same clothes, nobody looks richer or poorer than the others.
- James
Yes, that is a strong point.
- Layla
That protects students who cannot buy expensive things.
- James
I think that is the best argument too. Children can be unkind about trainers and brand names, and a uniform removes that problem.
- Sara
I understand that, but I'm not sure it works so well.
- Layla
Really? Why do you say that?
- Sara
In my school, we had no uniforms, and I still don't remember anyone being laughed at for their clothes.
- Layla
That is possible in some schools, Sara. But I have seen students feel embarrassed because their shoes were old. In those cases, the uniform really helps.
- Sara
Okay, that is fair. My main argument is self-expression.
- Layla
Please tell us more about that.
- Sara
School is the place where teenagers find out who they are, and clothes are one way to do that.
- James
But do you need clothes to find out who you are?
- Sara
Hmm, go on.
- James
I think you can show your personality in other ways, like your ideas, your hobbies and your friends.
- Sara
Maybe, but when I was fifteen, my clothes were a big part of my personality. If someone had taken that away, I would have felt very frustrated.
- Layla
I respect that, Sara. Still, I think students can express themselves after school, at weekends and on special days. School time is for learning.
- James
Some people also say that uniforms improve behaviour and results.
- Layla
Yes, I have heard that many times.
- James
I'm not sure that is true, to be honest. Some studies suggest there is no big difference.
- Layla
I agree with you there. A uniform will not make a lazy student work hard. But I do think it gives a school a feeling of being one team.
- Sara
A feeling of being one team. I like that idea, although I think a team can also be built with activities, sports and projects.
- James
Let's talk about money. People say uniforms are cheaper, but my parents spent a lot every year.
- Sara
Oh dear. That is a lot of money.
- James
The school shop was very expensive!
- Layla
That can be a real problem, James. In my school, parents can buy the uniform from any shop, and we also have a box of used uniforms for families who need help.
- Sara
That is a lovely idea. I think it shows that a good uniform policy needs to be fair, and not only strict.
- Layla
Exactly. Comfort matters as well.
- James
Especially in summer!
- Layla
In Dubai, the weather is very hot for many months, so the material has to be light, or the students will suffer.
- James
I wish my school had thought about that. In summer, we sat in heavy jackets, and nobody could think about maths.
- Sara
Here is a different question. Many Arab families like uniforms because they feel the school looks organised. Layla, do parents in your school think the same?
- Layla
Most of them do. They say it saves time and arguments in the morning.
- James
That is very practical.
- Layla
One father told me that he is happy because his son cannot spend an hour choosing a shirt.
- James
That sounds like my house! My little brother needs half an hour to decide which trainers to wear, even on a normal Saturday.
- Sara
Okay, I have to admit that a uniform makes the morning easier. However, I still think students should have some choice.
- Layla
I'm listening.
- Sara
What if schools allowed a simple uniform with some colours to choose from?
- Layla
I like that, and some schools already do it.
- Sara
Oh, that's great to hear.
- Layla
For example, students can choose between a skirt and trousers, or between a jumper and a jacket. It is a good compromise.
- James
A compromise sounds sensible. If I could go back to school, I would ask for a uniform without a tie, and I would be the happiest boy in the country.
- Sara
Let's take a short break from our big arguments and look at some useful English from our conversation.
- James
Good idea. The first expression is compromise.
- Sara
Compromise. Okay.
- James
A compromise is when two sides each give up a little to find a solution that both can accept.
- Layla
For example, I said that a uniform with some choice is a good compromise between rules and freedom.
- Sara
Nice example.
- Layla
You can also say that you reached a compromise with your parents about bedtime.
- Sara
The second word is self-expression. It means showing your feelings, ideas or personality, for example through clothes, art or music.
- James
And the third one is strict. A strict teacher or a strict rule is very serious, and you must follow it.
- Sara
Good to know.
- James
It is not the same as unfair, because a strict rule can still be fair.
- Layla
Yes. A strict dress code is not always a bad thing, but I prefer a school that explains the reasons behind its rules.
- Sara
Now, a question for both of you. Do you think uniforms will still exist in fifty years?
- James
I think so. Traditions are strong in schools, and many parents like them.
- Sara
That is true.
- James
But I imagine they will become more comfortable, with modern materials and more choice.
- Layla
I agree. And if schools listen to students, the rules will be better.
- James
Absolutely.
- Layla
In my school, we asked the students for their ideas last year, and they suggested a sports uniform for Fridays.
- Sara
That is a clever solution. Giving students a voice makes them accept the rules more easily, even when they do not like them.
- James
Here is another thing. If a student feels proud of the school, they will wear the uniform happily.
- Sara
Hmm, that's interesting.
- James
If they hate the school, they will hate the uniform too.
- Layla
That is so true, James.
- Sara
Well said.
- Layla
The uniform is only a small part of a much bigger picture, which is whether students feel safe and respected at school.
- Sara
I have to say, this conversation has changed my mind a little.
- Layla
I'm glad to hear that.
- Sara
I still love freedom, but I understand the value of equality and the simple morning.
- James
I have not changed my mind completely, because I still hate ties. But I do accept that uniforms help many students feel equal.
- Sara
Layla, before we finish, could you tell us about your best uniform memory?
- Layla
Yes. On the last day of school, all my friends and I signed our white scarves with colourful pens.
- James
Aw, that sounds wonderful.
- Layla
I kept mine for years, and it is still in my cupboard.
- James
That is a lovely memory. Maybe I will keep my school tie after all, but only as a souvenir!
- Sara
So let's finish with a quick summary. Uniforms can create equality, save time and build school spirit, but they can limit self-expression and can be expensive.
- James
My final opinion is that a simple, comfortable uniform with a little choice is the best answer. Layla, what is yours?
- Layla
I support uniforms, as long as schools keep them fair and affordable, and listen to the students. Sara, you have the last word.
- Sara
I'm still a little bit against, but I'm much more open now.
- James
That is progress!
- Sara
Now we have a question for you, our listeners. If you could design your own school uniform, what would it look like?
- James
Think about it, and share your ideas with a friend in English. It is great practice.
- Layla
Thank you for having me. It was a pleasure to talk with you both today.
- Sara
Thank you, Layla! That's all for today. Thanks for listening, keep practising your English, and goodbye!
- James
Goodbye everyone, and see you next time on Yalla Fluent Podcast!
Key vocabulary
uniform
special clothes that everyone in a school or group wears
equality
a situation where everyone is treated the same and has the same chances
self-expression
showing your feelings, ideas or personality
compromise
an agreement where each side gives up a little
strict
very serious about rules and expecting people to follow them
embarrassed
feeling shy or uncomfortable because of what people think
frustrated
feeling angry or upset because you cannot do what you want
affordable
not too expensive, so people can pay for it
personality
the way a person thinks, feels and behaves
comfortable
making you feel relaxed, with no pain or problem
souvenir
something you keep to remember a place or a time
sensible
showing good judgement and practical thinking
Did you understand?
Check your understanding
0 / 8 correct
1.Why did James hate his school tie?
2.What does Layla think is the strongest reason for uniforms?
3.What is Sara's main argument against uniforms?
4.What did James and his friends do to make their uniforms different?
5.How does Layla's school help families who cannot afford uniforms?
6.What compromise do the speakers like?
7.What did the students at Layla's school suggest last year?
8.How did Sara feel at the end of the discussion?