Meritocracy: Fair Ideal or Comforting Myth?
We all like to believe that talent and hard work decide who gets ahead. Two guests, a business lecturer and a start-up founder, ask how much of success is really earned and how much is simply luck.
In this episode
Sara
Host
James
Host
Rasha
a business school lecturer from Riyadh who now teaches in London
Rohan
a founder from Bengaluru who has started two companies
Press play to listen
0:00 / 12:07
Chapters
Transcript
Tap any line to listen from there.
- Sara
Hello everyone, and welcome to Yalla Fluent Podcast! I'm Sara, and I'm delighted to be back with you for another conversation.
- James
And I'm James. Today we're tackling an idea that almost everybody believes in, yet very few people can define properly: meritocracy, the notion that people rise purely on talent and effort.
- Sara
We have two wonderful guests. Rasha is a business school lecturer from Riyadh who now teaches in London, and she has spent years studying how people actually get promoted.
- James
And Rohan is a founder from Bengaluru who has started two companies, one of which failed rather spectacularly, so he has strong opinions about both success and humility.
- Rasha
Thank you both. I should warn you that I'm going to say something unpopular early on: I love the ideal of meritocracy, but I distrust the way we usually talk about it.
- Rohan
Happy to be here! I'm the one who built a career on hard work, so I'll be defending effort, although I promise to be honest about my luck too.
- James
A promise we will certainly hold you to!
- Sara
Let's start simply. When you hear a success story, a billionaire or a famous footballer, how much of it is talent, how much is effort, and how much is luck?
- Rohan
Honestly, I used to say it was mostly effort. I worked eighteen hours a day for years. But after my second company took off, I looked back and realised how many random things had to go right.
- James
Such as?
- Rohan
My first investor was the father of a university friend. I only got that meeting because we happened to share a dormitory corridor. Hindsight is a humbling teacher, because the same pitch from a stranger might have gone straight into the bin.
- James
So a friendship at the right moment was worth more than a perfect pitch?
- Rohan
In a sense, yes. The pitch mattered, but the door had to open first.
- Rasha
And that is what the research keeps finding. Some studies suggest that in youth football, the players born in the first months of the school year are chosen far more often, simply because they are a little bigger and older. Nobody intends it, yet it shapes entire careers.
- Sara
Wait, is that really a thing? The month someone is born?
- Rasha
Some studies suggest so, yes. It's called the relative age effect, if you want to look it up.
- James
That's wonderfully absurd. A birthday decides who becomes a professional. In Britain we have an old saying that it's not what you know but who you know, and I'm afraid it's still depressingly accurate in some industries.
- Rasha
It gets stranger. Teachers sometimes treat the most confident child as the cleverest, and the child lives up to that label for years.
- Rohan
That rings true. At my school, one boy was called a genius at seven, and he received better attention and more chances ever after.
- Sara
In America we have the opposite myth, the idea that anyone can pull themselves up by their bootstraps. Funnily enough, that phrase originally described something impossible, like lifting yourself off the ground by your own boots.
- Rasha
I love that fact, Sara. And here is another one. The word meritocracy was invented in the nineteen fifties by a British sociologist, Michael Young, in a satirical book. He meant it as a warning about a cruel society, not as a goal to aim for.
- Rohan
Really? So the word started life as an insult? That's a twist I did not expect.
- Rasha
Yes! He imagined a society where the clever few rule, and everyone else is told they deserve their place.
- James
Which makes it quite ironic that every politician and chief executive now says it with a straight face. But let's be fair to the ideal. Surely it beats the alternative, where your birth decides everything?
- Sara
Before we go on, Rohan, does your own success feel deserved to you? You sounded a little uncomfortable earlier.
- Rohan
Both, honestly. I earned parts of it, but I can never separate the earned part from the lucky part, and that uncertainty is why I now try to be generous.
- Rasha
Absolutely, James, it beats that. My concern is subtler. If you believe the system is perfectly fair, then every winner deserves everything and every loser deserves their fate.
- Sara
That's a sobering thought. So the winners become arrogant and the others blame themselves?
- Rasha
Precisely. Some research suggests that people who are reminded of their own luck become more generous. People who are told they earned everything tend to become more stingy and complacent. A philosopher named Michael Sandel wrote about this, calling it the tyranny of merit.
- Sara
The tyranny of merit. What a striking phrase.
- Rohan
I felt that from the other side. When my first company collapsed, I didn't just lose money. I decided I was personally worthless, because in my mind a fair world meant my failure was entirely my fault.
- Sara
That sounds painful. What changed your mind?
- Rohan
A mentor told me, very gently, that I had made two real mistakes and been hit by three things outside my control, including a supplier going bankrupt. Separating those out was a relief. Resilience is easier when you stop treating every setback as a verdict on your character.
- Sara
That is a very useful distinction, and I suspect many listeners need to hear it.
- Rasha
Yes, because blaming yourself entirely is just the myth of merit turned against the self.
- James
But let me play devil's advocate. If we stop believing in merit, don't we slide into something worse? Back home people complain about nepotism, jobs handed to cousins and old school friends. Merit is the weapon against that.
- Rasha
That's a fair challenge, James. In the Arab world we have the word wasta, which means using connections to get something done. Everyone knows it, many people resent it, and yet many have also used it quietly when their own family needed help.
- Sara
So is it fair to say that wasta is a social habit as much as a moral failing?
- Rasha
I think so. Loyalty to family is a good instinct, but when it blocks a stranger who is better qualified, it becomes a real problem.
- Rohan
Exactly. I'm not saying merit is a lie. I'm saying that without the ideal, we have no standard to measure favouritism against. The ideal is what lets us call out unfairness in the first place.
- Rasha
I agree with that completely. My quarrel is with the belief that we have already achieved it. An aspiration is healthy. A false description of reality is dangerous.
- Sara
So the real danger isn't the dream, it's the smugness. Does the smugness show up in hiring, too?
- Rasha
Constantly. Some studies suggest that identical applications get different responses depending on the name at the top. Managers who are most convinced of their own objectivity are sometimes the least careful, because they never check themselves.
- James
That's rather humbling. Confidence in your own fairness is the biggest blind spot of all.
- Sara
Which makes me wonder what a more honest story of success would sound like.
- Rasha
Less boasting about talent and more gratitude, I suspect. When someone thanks the people who helped them, I trust their story far more.
- Rohan
In my company we started giving every candidate the same technical test, with names removed before anyone marked it. Our team became more varied within a year, and it was nothing to do with charity. We simply stopped missing talented people.
- Sara
That reminds me of orchestras. I read that when musicians began auditioning behind a screen, more women were hired. Is that really true, Rasha?
- Rasha
Some researchers believe so, although later analysts have questioned the exact numbers. I would say the lesson survives either way: when you remove the information that shouldn't matter, you judge the work rather than the person.
- James
I like the image of a race. We spend ages arguing about who ran fastest, but hardly anybody asks whether everyone started on the same line.
- Sara
That's a great image, James. Who decides where the starting line is, though?
- Rohan
And some people start the race with a head start and a good pair of shoes. I'd add that fairness at the start isn't enough. You also need decent support along the way, like good schools, health care and a safety net when you stumble.
- Rasha
Which brings us to scholarships and mentoring. When I was a student, a scholarship took me from Riyadh to Britain. I worked hard, certainly, but the scholarship committee had the courage to bet on a teenager they had never met.
- Sara
Do you think that makes you less self-made, or more?
- Rasha
I think the phrase self-made is mostly a fantasy. Everyone is made by teachers, parents, neighbours and a lucky break or two. Admitting that doesn't diminish my effort. It simply puts my effort in context.
- Sara
That's a bold claim. Won't it upset people who really did struggle alone?
- James
I'm tempted to disagree a little. Some people really do climb from nothing through extraordinary determination, and calling their success mere luck feels insulting to them.
- Rasha
You're right, and I'd never call it mere luck. Their effort is real and it should be celebrated. I only want us to remember how steep their hill was compared with other people's.
- James
Fair enough. Then we agree that the hill is steeper for some.
- Rohan
So perhaps the healthiest attitude is double: take pride in your work, and take responsibility for the ladder you leave behind for others.
- Rasha
And that ladder matters. My uncle was the first in our family to attend university, and he spent decades quietly paying school fees for his cousins.
- James
That's a lovely example. Fairness isn't only for governments and companies. It happens at kitchen tables, over Arabic coffee, in countless small decisions.
- Sara
I love that. Pride and responsibility together. Now, before we wrap up, James has something for our language corner.
- James
Thanks, Sara. Three expressions came up today. The first is a level playing field. In sport it means a pitch with no slope, and in life it means a situation where everyone has the same chance of success.
- Sara
The second is born with a silver spoon in your mouth. It describes someone from a rich family who has enjoyed every advantage since birth. For example, you could say that a silver spoon helps, but it doesn't guarantee happiness.
- James
And the third is complacent, which describes someone so pleased with their position that they stop trying or stop noticing problems. Rohan warned us earlier that success can make people complacent.
- Rohan
Guilty as charged. Although I'd say a level playing field is the phrase that we should all try to use, and to act on, a little more often.
- James
Quite right. Try using each of these expressions once this week, learners, and they will soon feel natural.
- Rasha
Another useful word is hindsight, which means seeing clearly only after the event, exactly as happened to Rohan.
- Sara
Let's gather our thoughts. We started with the question of whether meritocracy is a fair ideal or a comforting myth, and it seems we found it is a bit of both. Rasha, where do you land?
- Rasha
I'd keep merit as a goal and drop it as a boast. We should reward talent and effort, while admitting that luck and background are always in the room.
- Rohan
My view has softened. I still believe in working hard, but I now believe even more in reaching out a hand. The people who succeed fastest are often the ones who were helped, and who pay it forward.
- James
I'm a cautious optimist. Believing in merit pushes us to be fair, provided we have the humility to check whether we really are. Rasha, Rohan, thank you for a wonderfully honest conversation.
- Sara
Now a question for you, our listeners. Think of one moment in your life when luck helped you more than you realised at the time, and think about how you could repay it. Thank you for listening to Yalla Fluent Podcast, and goodbye for now!
Key vocabulary
meritocracy
a system in which people succeed because of their talent and effort
humility
the quality of not thinking that you are better than other people
nepotism
giving jobs or advantages to your own relatives or friends instead of the best candidates
level playing field
a situation in which everyone has the same chance to succeed
silver spoon
the advantages of being born into a rich family
self-made
having become successful through your own efforts rather than help from others
complacent
so satisfied with yourself that you stop trying or stop noticing dangers
hindsight
understanding something only after it has happened
resilience
the ability to recover quickly after a difficult experience
aspiration
a strong hope or ambition to achieve something
blind spot
something you fail to notice or understand about yourself
bootstraps
the loops on boots, used in the phrase about succeeding through your own effort alone
Did you understand?
Check your understanding
0 / 7 correct
1.Why does Rohan say hindsight is a humbling teacher?
2.What was the original purpose of the word meritocracy, according to Rasha?
3.What is Rasha's main concern about believing that the system is perfectly fair?
4.How did Rohan's mentor help him after his first company collapsed?
5.Why does James warn against abandoning the idea of merit completely?
6.What change did Rohan's company make to its hiring?
7.How does Rasha feel about the phrase self-made?