Should Museums Return Their Treasures?
A curator from Jeddah and a heritage lawyer from Mumbai debate who really owns the world's famous artefacts, and whether a museum can ever be a fair guardian of objects taken in the age of empires.
In this episode
Sara
Host
James
Host
Ghada
a curator from Jeddah who works at a major museum in London
Rohan
a heritage lawyer from Mumbai who advises governments on cultural property
Press play to listen
0:00 / 12:52
Chapters
Transcript
Tap any line to listen from there.
- Sara
Hello everyone, and welcome to Yalla Fluent Podcast! I'm Sara, and I'm delighted to be back with you today.
- James
And I'm James. Today's question makes curators, historians and ordinary visitors argue with equal passion. Should museums return their treasures to the places those objects came from?
- Sara
We've invited two guests to help us untangle it. First, Ghada, who grew up in Jeddah and now works as a curator at a major museum in London. Welcome, Ghada!
- Ghada
Thank you, Sara. I should say that I'm speaking for myself, not my museum. I love these collections, yet I understand the anger.
- James
Our second guest is Rohan, a heritage lawyer from Mumbai who has advised several governments on recovering cultural property. Rohan, thanks for joining us.
- Rohan
My pleasure, James. I've worked in this field for fifteen years, so I have strong opinions. But I promise to listen, too.
- Sara
Let's start with the basics for anyone who hasn't followed the story. Which objects are we really talking about?
- James
A few famous cases appear again and again. The Rosetta Stone, the Parthenon Marbles, and the Benin Bronzes from what is now Nigeria. Many such objects were taken, bought or carried away in the age of empires.
- Rohan
The Benin Bronzes are a good place to begin. In eighteen ninety-seven, a British military expedition entered the Kingdom of Benin, and thousands of brass and ivory works were removed from the royal palace.
- Sara
Thousands of them? That's staggering. Were they just decorations, or did they mean more than that?
- Rohan
Far more. For many Nigerians they are the archives of a dynasty, the memory of their ancestors in metal.
- Sara
So it's a bit like someone taking your family's photo albums and hanging them in a stranger's living room, and then charging visitors to look at them.
- Rohan
That's exactly how many people feel, Sara. Although the stranger would probably reply that the albums were legally bought, and that's where it gets complicated.
- James
Legally bought, he says. I'm not so sure it's that simple.
- Ghada
It does. Some objects were plainly looted, and nobody can seriously deny it. Others were purchased or gifted under agreements that were legal at the time, even though the two sides were hopelessly unequal.
- James
Which makes me wonder whether a sale can be truly fair when one side held all the cards. If a powerful empire says, sell me this or else, is that consent?
- Rohan
That's my argument precisely. Consent under pressure isn't consent. When I open a file, I first ask about provenance, meaning the full history of who owned the object.
- Ghada
Provenance research matters, and museums were slow to do it. For decades the attitude was, it's been here for two hundred years, so why worry? That is no longer acceptable, and younger curators like me say so openly.
- Sara
Ghada, has this ever felt personal for you? You're an Arab curator working inside one of these institutions.
- Ghada
It has. A young Nigerian woman once visited our gallery and stood in front of a brass plaque for twenty minutes without speaking.
- James
What did she say in the end?
- Ghada
That her grandmother used to describe such images, and she had never imagined seeing them in London, behind glass. I felt proud and ashamed at the same time.
- James
That's a powerful story. Proud because the object is well cared for, perhaps, and ashamed because it's so far from home?
- Ghada
Exactly. Well cared for and yet displaced, and no clever lighting can fix that feeling.
- Sara
Let me bring in another famous case, the Parthenon Marbles. James, remind us what happened there.
- James
Gladly. In the early eighteen hundreds, Lord Elgin, a Scottish diplomat in the Ottoman Empire, removed large sections of sculpture from the Parthenon in Athens, and they ended up in the British Museum.
- Sara
But didn't he have permission to take them?
- James
His supporters say so, and that he perhaps saved the sculptures from damage. Greece says the permission was shaky and the sculptures belong with the building they were made for.
- Ghada
What strikes me is the emotional logic. Half a sculpture is in Athens and half is in London, and many visitors feel it's like seeing half of a face. I can see why that resonates.
- Rohan
It resonates because it's about integrity. Each case has its own logic, which is why blanket rules are dangerous in either direction.
- James
Blanket rules rarely work in history, I suppose.
- Sara
That's a good point. But let me play devil's advocate. Museums say that visitors from every country can see world cultures under one roof. Isn't that a precious thing?
- Ghada
It's the so-called universal museum argument, and it has real value. A student from Riyadh or Lagos can compare Egyptian, Greek, Chinese and Persian art in one building.
- Rohan
I accept that, but notice the word universal. Whose universe? Those museums sit in a few wealthy capitals, and the cost of a flight and a visa puts them out of reach for most people from the countries whose treasures they display.
- Ghada
That's fair. Their second argument is safety. Some institutions say they have the expertise and security to protect fragile objects for centuries, and sadly there have been cases of theft and damage in various countries, including wealthy ones.
- James
Careful, Ghada. There's a hint of that old argument that other countries can't look after their own history, and it sounds a little patronising.
- Ghada
It can sound that way, and I don't want it to. Frankly, that argument is getting weaker every year.
- Rohan
It certainly is. Look at the Grand Egyptian Museum near the pyramids, or the Acropolis Museum in Athens, which opened in two thousand and nine with a gallery designed to hold the Parthenon Marbles. Greece essentially said, you claimed we had nowhere to put them, so we built somewhere.
- Sara
Ghada, how do you answer that? It sounds as though one of the museums' best arguments has just disappeared.
- Ghada
The remaining arguments are legal. In Britain, a law passed in nineteen sixty-three stops the British Museum from giving away items in its collection, apart from a few narrow exceptions. So even a willing director's hands are tied.
- James
And there's the slippery slope worry, isn't there? If you return the Rosetta Stone, what about the thousands of other items? Do the museums end up half empty?
- Rohan
I hear that fear constantly, and I think it's exaggerated. Nobody serious is demanding that every museum empty its galleries. Most claims concern objects that were clearly looted, or that have ceremonial or royal meaning for living communities.
- Sara
I understand the fear, though. A museum director would worry about setting a precedent.
- James
Yes, but I'd say the precedent has already been set. In two thousand and twenty-two, Germany agreed to transfer ownership of many Benin Bronzes in its museums to Nigeria, and the sky did not fall.
- Rohan
Exactly, and the world carried on.
- Ghada
That's true, and I watched it closely. Interestingly, some pieces were then allowed to stay in Germany on loan. That tells us something important, which is that return doesn't have to mean goodbye.
- Sara
Ghada, you grew up in Saudi Arabia. Does the Gulf have a different relationship with this issue, now that so many new museums are opening?
- Ghada
It does, in an interesting way. Countries in our region are building museums at remarkable speed, and some borrow objects from older European institutions. The Louvre Abu Dhabi, for instance, works with French museums.
- Sara
So the region is becoming a home for museums, not only a source of objects.
- Rohan
And that changes the balance of power. When more countries have world-class museums, the old arguments about safety and access lose their force, and the conversation shifts from whether to how.
- James
I find that reassuring. So let's explore the middle ground. If the choice isn't simply keep or return, what are the other options?
- Ghada
Loans are the most common one. A museum transfers ownership, and the original country then lends objects back for exhibitions abroad. Another idea is shared custody, where two institutions look after a piece together.
- Rohan
I like those ideas when ownership is settled first. My concern is a loan offered instead of a return, which keeps the power exactly where it was. It's the difference between being a guest in your own house and being its owner.
- James
Still, I wonder about the digital option. These days we can scan an object in extraordinary detail and print an almost perfect copy. Could a replica satisfy both sides?
- Sara
My instinct says no, but let's ask Rohan.
- Rohan
Honestly, I think a replica is a poor consolation. A copy of a royal crown is not a crown. It has no history.
- Sara
What about when the answer isn't clear? Borders have changed so much that an ancient statue might come from a place that today sits in three different countries.
- Ghada
That's one of the hardest cases, and no single formula can solve it. Each claim needs its own investigation. Which community still has a living connection to it?
- James
Let me share a quick story. My nephew asked why a mummy lives in London when mummies come from Egypt. I said it was a long story, and he said, then I want to hear it.
- Sara
Children ask the obvious question! I think it's the best test. If the honest answer to why is this here includes the words because we took it, the museum should feel uncomfortable.
- Ghada
I agree, though discomfort alone shouldn't decide the matter. Some museums now write acquired during a military expedition on their labels, instead of donated.
- Rohan
Better labels are welcome, but let's not pretend a label is a solution. A label is an apology that costs nothing.
- James
Ouch, that's a sharp line, Rohan! Ghada, any rebuttal?
- Ghada
A label is a beginning, not an ending. To be fair, public pressure has pushed museums further than any lawyer has. So ask questions when you visit. Curators notice.
- Sara
Before we wrap up, let's take a short language corner. Three useful expressions came up today. James, would you start us off?
- James
Happily. The first is provenance. It means the history of ownership of an object. You can use it for paintings, antiques or a rare book.
- Ghada
A very handy word for essays about history or art, too.
- Sara
The second is a phrase I enjoyed, to hold all the cards. If you hold all the cards, you have all the power in a situation.
- Ghada
And the third is repatriate, or the noun repatriation. It means sending something or someone back to their country of origin. People often use it for objects, but it also applies to citizens who have been stranded abroad.
- James
Well, that brings us to our final thoughts. Rohan, where do you stand after all this?
- Rohan
I remain firmly in favour of return when objects were taken by force. But this conversation reminded me that how we return matters as much as whether we do. Partnerships and shared research can turn a bitter dispute into a friendship.
- Ghada
I've moved a little. I still believe in great collections that tell a global story, but the burden of proof lies with the museum. If we can't explain honestly how an object came to us, we shouldn't keep it.
- James
That's a brave thing for a curator to admit.
- Sara
For me, it comes down to respect. Objects aren't only things, they're memories for living people. Museums can be wonderful guardians, but guardians must listen to the people whose stories they hold.
- James
I'd say the era of just keeping it because we always have is over, and good riddance.
- Sara
Here's a question for you at home. Imagine a treasure from your own country is sitting in a faraway museum. Would you want it back, or be glad that the world can see it?
- Ghada
Thank you both. It was a pleasure, and a challenging one.
- James
Thank you to Ghada and Rohan for such a thoughtful conversation. And do visit a museum this week. Ask a question or two while you're there.
- Rohan
Thanks for having me. I'll keep listening to the other side, I promise.
- Sara
Thank you for listening to Yalla Fluent Podcast. Keep practising your English, and we'll see you next time. Goodbye!
Key vocabulary
untangle
to make a confusing or complicated situation clear
curator
a person who looks after and organises the objects in a museum
looted
stolen from a place, especially during a war or disaster
hold all the cards
to have all the power in a situation
provenance
the history of who owned an object and where it came from
displaced
moved away from its proper or original place
patronising
treating people as if they are less intelligent or capable than you
slippery slope
a situation where one small step leads to bigger, worse changes
precedent
an earlier action or decision that is used as an example for later ones
consolation
something that makes you feel better when you have lost something else
repatriate
to send something or someone back to their country of origin
burden of proof
the duty to show that something is true
Did you understand?
Check your understanding
0 / 7 correct
1.What does Rohan say is the first thing he asks about when he opens a file on an object?
2.What happened when a young Nigerian woman visited Ghada's gallery?
3.Why does Rohan think the safety argument is now weak?
4.According to Ghada, what legal obstacle exists in Britain?
5.What did Germany agree to do in 2022, according to James?
6.What is Rohan's opinion of a replica of a royal crown?
7.How does Ghada's view change by the end of the episode?