Space Tourism: Adventure or Excess?
Billionaires are buying tickets to the edge of space, but is it inspiring exploration or an expensive indulgence? Our guests weigh the cost, the carbon footprint and the future of travelling beyond Earth.
In this episode
Sara
Host
James
Host
Dalia
a space policy researcher from Riyadh who studied in London
Marcus
an aerospace journalist who has covered rocket launches in Texas and Florida
Press play to listen
0:00 / 12:02
Chapters
Transcript
Tap any line to listen from there.
- Sara
Hello everyone, and welcome to Yalla Fluent Podcast! I'm Sara, and today we are looking up, quite literally, at the night sky and the people who want to travel into it.
- James
And I'm James. Our topic is space tourism, which used to be pure science fiction and is now something a handful of wealthy people can actually book, provided their bank balance is comfortably astronomical.
- Sara
Joining us are two guests with very different perspectives. Dalia is a space policy researcher who grew up in Riyadh, and Marcus is an aerospace journalist who has stood in the heat of Texas watching rockets lift off. Welcome, both of you.
- Dalia
Thank you, Sara. I should say upfront that I'm a cautious enthusiast.
- Sara
A cautious enthusiast. I like that.
- Dalia
I love anything that gets people excited about space, but I'm not convinced the current model is the best way to do it.
- Marcus
Thanks for having me. And I'll admit I'm the optimist at this table.
- Dalia
We'll see about that.
- Marcus
I think we're watching the start of something as significant as the first commercial airlines, even if it looks absurdly expensive right now.
- James
Wonderful, a disagreement before we've even started. Marcus, let's begin with the obvious question. Who is actually going up there?
- Marcus
Mostly very wealthy individuals, so far. In the summer of two thousand and twenty-one, Richard Branson and Jeff Bezos both made short flights within days of each other, and the media called it the billionaire space race.
- James
A billionaire space race, indeed.
- Marcus
Tickets for those suborbital trips cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, and some seats sold for far more.
- Sara
And those flights only lasted about ten minutes, didn't they? You go up, you float for a few minutes, and you come straight back down.
- Marcus
Exactly, you cross the line at the edge of space, you see the curve of the Earth, and then gravity reclaims you.
- James
Ten minutes of weightlessness, then.
- Dalia
What interests me is that the passenger list is slowly widening. In two thousand and twenty-three, two Saudi astronauts, Rayyanah Barnawi and Ali AlQarni, flew to the International Space Station on a private mission.
- Sara
I remember that mission. It was a proud moment across the Gulf.
- Dalia
That felt different from a billionaire joyride, because it was about national science and representation.
- James
That's an important distinction. Is a trip like that really tourism, or is it something else wearing a tourist's clothes?
- Dalia
I'd say it's a grey area. The commercial company sold the seats, but the astronauts trained for months and carried out real experiments.
- Marcus
I'd push back slightly, though. Nobody complained when the first airline passengers were wealthy adventurers paying a fortune for a bumpy flight.
- Sara
That's a fair analogy, but I wonder whether space will ever follow the same curve. Flying a plane is hard, but getting to orbit is brutally hard.
- Marcus
It is, but reusable rockets have changed the arithmetic. That alone has pushed the cost of reaching orbit down significantly.
- James
Is it simply wrong to spend that kind of money on a ten-minute thrill while problems here on Earth remain unsolved?
- Dalia
That's the argument I hear most often, and I understand the frustration. When you compare a single ticket to what that money could do for clean water or schools, the contrast is uncomfortable.
- James
That is quite a contrast, isn't it?
- Dalia
However, I try to be intellectually honest. Wealthy people spend money on yachts and private jets without anyone writing a thesis about it. So the real question is whether space deserves to be judged more harshly than other luxuries.
- Marcus
Right, and I'd argue it should be judged more kindly, because the money flows into engineering.
- Sara
I love that in theory, but I've heard the spin-off argument used to defend almost everything. Can you give a concrete example?
- Marcus
Fair challenge. Satellite technology is the clearest one.
- Sara
Yes, I use those every single day.
- Marcus
The weather forecasts on your phone, the navigation that gets you to a restaurant in Jeddah, even the way farmers monitor their crops, all of that grew out of an investment in space.
- Dalia
True, but notice that those benefits came mostly from government programmes aimed at science, not from a private company selling a thrill. I'd like to see tourism fund the research, rather than replace it.
- Marcus
Funding both would be ideal, of course.
- James
Which brings us to the inspiration argument. Billionaires like to say that watching a launch makes a child want to become an engineer. Is that wishful thinking, or does it hold up?
- Marcus
I've seen it with my own eyes.
- Sara
Really? Tell us more.
- Marcus
At one launch, a boy next to me was shaking with excitement, and his mother told me he had been building paper rockets all year.
- Dalia
I don't doubt that moment is real. My concern is that a launch watched on a screen inspires, but a ticket costing a fortune excludes.
- James
That's a sobering thought.
- Dalia
If the story becomes only about the rich, a lot of ordinary children might conclude that space simply isn't for them.
- Sara
That's a powerful point. I remember reading that when one famous actor flew to space, he came back deeply emotional and spoke about feeling grief for the planet.
- Dalia
Yes, I read about his reaction too.
- Sara
Doesn't that kind of experience change how a person thinks?
- Marcus
That's often called the overview effect. Astronauts repeatedly say that seeing the Earth as a fragile blue marble, with no borders drawn on it, makes them feel more protective of it.
- James
That's a beautiful idea.
- Marcus
If wealthy passengers feel that, perhaps they'll use their influence for good.
- Dalia
Perhaps. But I'd be more convinced if we saw evidence of that change in behaviour, rather than a beautiful speech followed by another flight.
- Sara
Fair point. Actions matter more than speeches.
- James
Which is a lovely, if slightly pointed, way of leading us to the elephant in the room. Rockets burn a lot of fuel. What do we actually know about the environmental cost?
- Dalia
Honestly, we know less than we should.
- Sara
That's a surprising thing to admit.
- Dalia
Some studies suggest that, per passenger, a short rocket flight produces far more emissions than a long-haul flight, simply because so few people share the fuel.
- Marcus
That's true per seat, but we need to keep perspective. The total number of launches is tiny compared with the millions of commercial flights every year, so the overall contribution is currently small.
- Dalia
Currently is the crucial word. What worries scientists is where the exhaust is released.
- James
Where it goes matters as much as how much.
- Dalia
Soot and other particles deposited high in the atmosphere can stay there far longer than they would near the ground, and their effect on the climate is not yet well understood.
- Sara
So there's a real risk we scale up an industry before understanding the consequences.
- Marcus
It does, and I won't pretend otherwise. But companies are experimenting with cleaner fuels, and the sector is young enough to be regulated sensibly.
- Dalia
I agree regulation is the key, though I'm sceptical about how quickly it arrives.
- Marcus
Slow, but not hopeless.
- James
Let me play devil's advocate. Some people argue that the planet already has enough problems, and that every rocket launched for fun is a kind of insult to the effort of ordinary people reducing their own footprint. Is that fair?
- Dalia
It's emotionally fair, even if the numbers are small. Symbolism matters in public life.
- Sara
Symbolism is powerful, that's true.
- Dalia
When ordinary families are asked to recycle and use less water, a rocket launched for pleasure sends an awkward message.
- Marcus
I'd add that symbolism cuts both ways. The same companies are also building satellites that track deforestation, melting ice and methane leaks.
- Sara
That's interesting, Marcus. So the same industry that adds to the problem also helps us measure it. Dalia, does that soften your view at all?
- Dalia
A little, yes. It complicates my argument rather than destroying it.
- Sara
So tourism is the weak link.
- Dalia
I'd still say tourist flights are the least defensible part of the industry, while the satellites are the most valuable.
- James
Let's look ahead now. Marcus, if we fast-forward thirty years, what does an ordinary space holiday look like?
- Marcus
I think we'll see orbital hotels, perhaps small ones at first, and flights to the Moon for those who can afford them.
- Sara
Hotels in orbit? That sounds incredible.
- Marcus
Prices may drop to the level of a very luxurious cruise rather than a family trip, but I genuinely believe it will keep falling.
- Dalia
I'm more cautious. The physics of rockets has not changed, and safety will always be a limiting factor.
- James
A sobering reminder.
- Sara
Safety is a point I don't want to skip. Are ordinary passengers really protected, or are they effectively taking part in an experiment?
- Marcus
Passengers sign documents acknowledging the risk, and the rules are lighter than for airlines on purpose, to let the industry develop.
- Dalia
And that is exactly my worry. A culture of informed consent works for adventurers, but a mass market needs far stricter oversight.
- Marcus
That I agree with entirely.
- James
I'll offer a more personal angle. Would either of you actually go, if someone handed you a free ticket tomorrow?
- Marcus
In a heartbeat. I'd be terrified, and I'd probably embarrass myself on the way up, but I've spent my career describing launches from a field.
- Sara
I can picture you in the seat already.
- Marcus
I'd love to see the other side of that glass.
- Dalia
I would, and that probably makes me a hypocrite. I'd feel guilty about the emissions, but I'd also want to understand what the astronauts keep describing. Perhaps wanting to go and wanting it to be fairer are not mutually exclusive.
- Sara
I think that's honest, and it might be the most human answer we could hear. Before we wrap up, let's take a quick detour into the language corner.
- James
Welcome to the language corner. Our first expression today is the elephant in the room, which we used earlier. It means an obvious, uncomfortable problem that everyone can see but nobody wants to mention.
- Sara
For example, in a family meeting about a holiday budget, the elephant in the room might be that nobody has any savings. Our second phrase is in a heartbeat, which means immediately and without hesitation.
- James
Third, we heard the phrase to play devil's advocate. It means arguing against an idea, not because you disagree with it, but to test how strong the argument really is.
- Sara
Right, back to the discussion. Dalia, you mentioned fairness. Is there a version of space tourism that you could wholeheartedly support?
- Dalia
Yes. One where seats are partly funded for teachers, scientists and students, where the fuel is cleaner, and where flights contribute real data. If tourism supports science, I'm all for it.
- Marcus
I'd happily sign that proposal. My final view is that curiosity is worth protecting.
- James
Well said.
- Marcus
Space tourism may look excessive today, but excess has often been the first step toward something everyone eventually benefits from.
- Sara
For me, it sits somewhere between adventure and excess. I love the courage and the wonder, but I want the benefits shared and the planet protected before the queue gets any longer.
- James
And I'm torn, which is probably the honest position. If a ticket helped a clever teenager in Cairo become an engineer, I'd call that a bargain. If it only paid for a selfie at the edge of space, I'd raise an eyebrow.
- Sara
Here is a question for you, our listeners. If you were offered a free seat to space, would you take it, and what would you hope to bring back? Tell us what you think on our website.
- James
Thank you so much to Dalia and Marcus for a thoughtful and spirited conversation. And thank you all for listening to Yalla Fluent Podcast.
- Dalia
It was a pleasure. Keep looking up, and keep asking difficult questions.
- Marcus
Thanks for having me. Goodbye, everyone, and may your own journeys be a little less expensive.
- Sara
Goodbye, everyone, and see you next time!
Key vocabulary
suborbital
describing a flight that reaches space but does not go all the way around the Earth
astronomical
extremely large, especially when talking about an amount of money
spin-off
a useful thing that develops as a side result of other work
overview effect
the strong feeling astronauts have when they see the whole Earth from space
emissions
gases and particles released into the air, for example from engines
sceptical
doubting that something is true or will work
regulation
official rules that control how something is done
wholeheartedly
in a way that shows complete and enthusiastic support
the elephant in the room
an obvious problem that everyone knows about but avoids talking about
in a heartbeat
immediately and without any hesitation
devil's advocate
a person who argues against an idea to test it, even if they agree with it
mutually exclusive
two things that cannot both be true or happen at the same time
Did you understand?
Check your understanding
0 / 8 correct
1.Why does Dalia describe the flight of the two Saudi astronauts as different from a billionaire joyride?
2.What does Marcus compare early space tourists to?
3.According to Dalia, what is her main worry about the inspiration argument?
4.Why are scientists concerned about rocket exhaust?
5.What positive point does Marcus make about space companies and the environment?
6.What is Dalia's view of safety rules for space tourism?
7.What version of space tourism would Dalia wholeheartedly support?
8.How does James describe his own final position?